Rick Baker Thought Posts
Left Menu Space Holder

About the author

Name of author Rick Baker, P.Eng.

E-mail me Send mail
Follow me LinkedIn Twitter

Search

Calendar

<<  November 2024  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
28293031123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
2526272829301
2345678

View posts in large calendar

Recent Comments

Comment RSS

Thought Tweet #724

by Rick Baker
On Apr 25, 2013

Thought Tweet #724 Judge others carefully & know emotions cloud the truth. Believe emotions reveal the truth & judge others harshly.

 

The Thinking Behind The Tweet

It's not a question of right or wrong. It's just a couple of observations. 

Emotions [in contrast to feelings] are vestiges of formerly-useful genetically ingrained information.

Thoughts & judgments are matters of some choice. Expressions of thoughts & judgments are matters of more choice.

Thought Tweet #712

by Rick Baker
On Apr 9, 2013

Thought Tweet #712 Judge others' actions with balance...be sparing in frequency, be extra-considerate of situations, and be sincere.

 

The Thinking Behind The Tweet

Know your judgment is likely to sting.

Anticipate the scenarios of reaction.

If you must judge, be a creative judge.

Constructive Criticism is an Oxymoron 

The Danger in Negative Feedback

by Rick Baker
On Mar 11, 2013

For most people, the feedback scales have been skewed in the direction of negativity and 'my perception is right and whatever you’re thinking and doing is wrong'. For most people, this skew has existed since…well, since before they can remember.

Few people, if any, have been recipients of mostly appreciations and positive opinions’. I have met none of them. If we do meet people who have received excessive ‘appreciations and positive feedback’ then perhaps we can feel confident they have put that positivity to good use and their skin is thick enough to take negative criticism.

The rest of us, the vast majority that have been the recipients of excessive negative feedback, need to be handled with more care. 

I'm saying that with as objective a voice as I'm able to come up with. I am not making a moral judgement that 'more care' is the morally-correct thing to do, although for many people that will be the case. I am simply stating that we will achieve better results of we handle performance feedback with more care.

Note: for many years, I have argued in favour of Thick Skin. To the extent we thicken up our skin we do not need to be handled with such care. But, few people take the time and effort to thicken up their skin. Few people have mentors, coaches, or teachers to help them thicken up their skin. And, when it comes to feedback, thin-skinned people need to be handled with care.

Here’s my view: Based on my experience, well-packaged negative feedback will be received poorly by about 50% of people. Poorly-packaged negative feedback will be received poorly by 99% of people. When I say “received poorly” I mean it will not ‘construct’ the outcome the deliverer of the negative feedback desires. Perhaps, 1% of the time, negative/critical feedback can be constructive. This happens when well-packaged negative feedback meets a confident, high-self-image person. The other 99% of the time it cannot be constructive because it is either poorly delivered or poorly received.

That's why I say ‘Constructive Criticism is an Oxymoron’. 

Constructive criticism is an oxymoron and negative feedback does not work because most people cannot deliver it properly and most people cannot receive it properly.

Why?

Most people's skin is too thin.

&

Most people's skulls are too thick.

 

 

Here's the picture... 

Tags:

Criticism: Constructive Criticism is an Oxymoron | Thick Skin & Thin Skull

Thought Tweet #682

by Rick Baker
On Feb 26, 2013

Thought Tweet #682 Negative feedback works when it is well-packed and the recipient of it has high self-confidence.

 

The Thinking Behind The Tweet

That's the good news.

Here's a picture of the not-so-good news...

Tags:

Criticism: Constructive Criticism is an Oxymoron | Thought Tweets

Thought Tweet #681

by Rick Baker
On Feb 25, 2013

Thought Tweet #681 Does leadership mean delicate hands at the controls? Sometimes, Yes; Sometimes, Definitely NO. 

 


The Thinking Behind The Tweet

Most of the time - 99% of the time - Leaders should be supportive. Why? Because constructive criticism is an oxymoron

Most of the time - let's think in terms of a bell curve, so about 2/3 of the time - Leaders need to be in the clear-to-assertive range. That does not mean aggressive...it means assertive. In the clear-to-assertive range - Leaders need to be unemotional, concise, emphatic, and firm...but not intimidating or aggressive.

Sometimes, Leaders need to be very firm...so firm, others may find them aggressive. Here's an example: say you are a leader and one of the people you lead is an office bully; say you have exhausted all clear-to-assertive methods and the office bully does not correct his or her behaviour. In this scenario, you may find a very firm, even aggressive reaction is the only way to remedy the unacceptable bully-behaviour.

Perhaps, natural-born leaders can perform like this without pre-thought or planning...'ad-libbing'. I wouldn't rely on ad-libbing. I recommend thinking about tough situations in advance - thinking about the scenarios that could happen when the office bully is around:

  • planning your Leadership response; 
  • planning whether or not you will respond in a firm-aggressive; 
  • thinking through exactly how you will do that; 
  • thinking about how you will control your emotions so you will be in control of the situation;
  • choosing your words and body language in advance;
  • practicing, as required, to ensure you perform at your best

When you are delivering firm-aggressive messages you are not being constructive...at least, the recipient of your message will not feel or think you are being constructive. However, sometimes, a ruling with an iron fist is the only way to control a bully. 

Bullies are asking for iron-fist assertive leadership.

They are crying out for it.

Take care though - you must deliver it to bullies properly.

The wrinkle in customer complaints

by Rick Baker
On Nov 30, 2012

There's a wrinkle in customer complaints.

The wrinkle has a couple of waves:

  • wave #1 - Customer complaints are legitimate, whether you agree or not. When seeing things from the clients' shoes it matters little what you think. What matters is how clients feel and think. Their complaints signal their feelings. Their complaints signal their perspectives about your weaknesses.
  • wave #2 - Constructive criticism is an oxymoron. And that's the way your people are prone to receive customer complaints.
How do you iron out customer complaint wrinkles?
 
Be interested.
Listen.
Think.
Ask questions.
Listen.
Seek & discover solutions.
 

Tags:

Criticism: Constructive Criticism is an Oxymoron

Copyright © 2012. W.F.C (Rick) Baker. All Rights Reserved.